How the premium is measured
USDA reports organic and conventional product on separate lines, so the premium can be measured directly, week by week:
- Take the week's average price per pound for organic quotes of the commodity.
- Take the same week's average price per pound for conventional quotes.
- The premium is how much higher the organic price is, as a percentage of the conventional price.
Three rules make that number trustworthy:
- Both sides need real data. A week counts only when organic and conventional each have at least 3 USDA quotes. Otherwise the premium for that week is left out rather than computed from one or two lines.
- One price basis at a time. The premium is measured at FOB or at terminal, never on a mix of the two. On ProduceTrends we use whichever basis has more weeks where both sides are quoted, and the card names it.
- Enough history. With fewer than 10 weeks where both sides overlap, there is not enough to read, and we do not show a premium at all.
For a steadier recent figure, we pool the last 4 weeks and compare that with the same 4 weeks a year earlier.
Why it narrows and widens
The premium is not a fixed markup; it moves through the season.
- It usually narrows at the organic supply peak. When the most organic product is coming to market, its price comes closest to conventional. For buyers that dip is the organic buying window.
- Single weeks wiggle. One week's premium can jump just because a different mix of packs was quoted that week. Read the trend over several weeks, not one point.
- The long trend is the real signal. A premium that holds year after year is a different business from one that is sliding toward the conventional line.
Why FOB and terminal premiums can differ
FOB and terminal are different markets, so the organic premium at the shipping point and at a city wholesale market are two separate numbers. They can differ a lot.
That is why a pooled premium misleads, and why you should compare against the side you actually trade on:
- Growers and shippers selling at the shipping point: the FOB premium.
- Buyers on a terminal market: the terminal premium.
The premium at retail
Grocery chains advertise organic and conventional prices too, so there is an advertised retail premium alongside the wholesale one. The gap between the two is information:
For suppliers, that gap is negotiating ammunition.
Using it
- Buyers: watch for the seasonal narrowing; that is the window to lock in organic programs.
- Growers considering organic: judge the transition on the premium's trend across seasons, on the basis you will actually sell at, not on one good year.
- Suppliers: compare the wholesale premium with the advertised retail premium before a price talk.
- Everyone: keep organic and conventional apart in your own numbers. Organic quotes are much sparser than conventional ones, so expect more gaps and thinner weeks on the organic side.